Medical Costs....

-
Today morning, I was listening to a piece on NPR about how a hospital has dealt with an illegal immigrant from Guatemala who met with an accident and rendered brain dead... Hospital claims that it has spent more than a million USD and eventually rented a charter plane and deported him to his home country with a State Court's permission.... Of course, there are legal battles going on now (What do you expect, then?!?!) whether it is right or wrong.... For me, the bigger picture is - A 'well-developed', 'G-8' and a 'Superpower' seems to have trouble treating a single human being, citing the cost associated with it... So, USA cannot take care of a single human being because he doesn't have health insurance! I am not here to justify the immigration part or legality of the illegal immigrant's rights... There are of course millions of US citizens who can't afford health insurance. Is it really the people to be blamed for their ability (or inability) to afford?? Let me take an example. One of my friends had to undergo an expensive diagnosis here in US. He was able to afford it somehow and it costed $x. During a visit to India, they had to undergo again the same diagnosis. Surprisingly, the instrument was the same that was used in US and diagnosis was the same procedure. Do you know how much it costed, without even an insurance?? Only 1/10 the the cost... So, what is missing here..
  1. Are Doctors's charging too much here in US for their time? - We see stories where Doctor's close their practice because they couldn't take care of the malpractice insurance and so on... Of course, compared to WWII time, Doctors get paid many fold more compared to other professions.. Somehow, other professions haven't got the same treatment, anyway..
  2. Are hospitals charging too much and paying their staff too much? - We also see stories where Nurses are fighting for their pay increases eventhough the country doesn't have enough nurses to fill the needed positions.
  3. That leaves us with insurance companies...........

So, I have decided to bash the big corporate insurance companies.... Not really!! It is the entire system that needs to be blamed.... Paul Krugman has a nice explanation here in his weekly friday column at NY Times. Well, most of his suggestions go for a government intervention in everything (Keynesian?) from economy to healthcare. Let us just stick to Healthcare.. I am no economist and I am grazing the superficial layers here... How can a good, reputed hospital in India can charge only 10% of what a hospital in US would charge for the same test/diagnosis... Krugman's article partially explains where all your money is going - to underwriting and blah, blah, blah....

Why can't the government subsidise the Medical education? Wow, that would flood the market with many more doctors and nurses with lesser individual pay. Wouldn't it? Isn't that what a market economy would do - fix the pay and salary depending on the demand/supply theory? When Cuba can subsidise Medical education, why can't USA? Well, there will be an argument on the 'quality' of education, which I won't buy... A developed, innovative and rich country like US should be able to come up with a system to deal with it, if only enough thought and resources put in it to deal with...

When a medical treatment becomes affordable, having insurance won't be mandatory, rather a choice.. You do see those small clinics successfully branching out in several places in US, like in Walmarts and strip malls... People without insurance are flocking these places and are able to get quality care at affordable prices.. Don't they??

Comments

  1. AnonymousDecember 18, 2009 at 9:27 AM

    This one, I will agree with you one hundred percent about the ills and solution of US health care.

    One more thing to add is there has to be incentive for being a responsible healthy individual (eating properly, exercise etc). Well implementing this could pose its own problems but then we live in a country known for creativeness

    Aravind

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Belize (Feb 2024)

-
Image
We decided to go to Belize as it happened to be an escape from the chilly Northeast for a few days. It turned to be a wonderful trip not only for the climate, but had so much to offer for such a small country. It has the Caribbean vibe with sunny beaches, historic relevance with its Mayan ruins and greenery that feeds a diverse flora and fauna. After landing in Belize City, we took a ride to San Ignacio that took about 2.5 hours including a lunch stop at a ‘ Cheers’ (with a tropical twist 😊 ) on the way. The meal was refreshing with a view of their lushy farm in the backdrop. By the time we reached the Crystal Paradise Resort Hotel , it was almost dark. Checked in and had dinner right there as this place was away from the town. During dinner, we indicated to the concierge that we want to combine bird watching on our way to the Caracol Mayan Ruins. Caracol The trip was only for the two of us and the guide AbimaelMoralez was an excellent guy who has keen eyes and ears. Just the
Read more

Costa Rica (Feb 2018)

-
Image
Pura Vida – Costa Rica!!! (For the list of wildlife that we had the pleasure to see, here is the link  ) After some of our friends had visited Costa Rica in the past few years, we had been contemplating on when to do that. We planned the whole thing in a couple of months and did it. Turned out to be a wonderful trip. Costa Rica is interesting from several different points of view – promotion of eco-tourism, nestled between Nicaragua and Panama, without a military force, safest country in Central America, etc., Though Costa Rica is considered a poor country, it is not a cheap place for tourism. One can expect nothing less than the expenses in US. Initially, we were planning to cover the Arenal, Monteverde and Manual Antonio areas, but after reading more about the Osa Peninsula, we decided to spend half the time in Osa and the rest in Arenal area, doing White Water rafting in-between. One lesson we learned – don’t bother getting Colon at the airport. Almost all the places in t
Read more

Iceland - Land of Fire and Ice (August 2018)

-
Image
Iceland was a relatively recent quest for us after seeing the videos of its unique landscape and hearing from some of our friends who have visited recently. It was a really difficult choice to decide on what to cover during our visit – Do we do try to drive along the coast (mostly) of the entire island, like many do?! Do we select only a few spots and immerse in its beauty?! In the end, we decided to do only some selective spots as we didn’t want to strain ourselves too much in setting up some lofty goals like touring the entire island. It’s a small piece of island, but still the span is too much to drive around and still take a breather to enjoy each location. So, it turned to be a good choice for us! For the people closer to the east coast of US, it was just 5+ hrs from Boston. IcelandAir seats are relatively more roomier than typical American airlines. One you land in Reykjavik, you can see how big a tourist destination Iceland is by the sheer size of the huge queue for immigrat
Read more